Two candidates for the Senate–Sen. Mark Begich and Dan Sullivan–shared the stage in Fairbanks with House candidates Rep. Don Young, Democrat Forrest Dunbar and Libertarian candidate Jim McDermott. The forum was sponsored by the Greater Fairbanks Chamber of Commerce.
With such big personalities on stage, many thought that the forum would be filed with fireworks. Judging from the twitter feed, and from reports back, the fireworks were kind of duds. The Senate race took up most of the air in the room, and at this point, those two candidates are so scripted that spontaneity was virtually impossible. The one piece of news, if you want to call it that, that came out of the forum was when Begich said that although he didn’t support the Pebble Mine, he also didn’t support EPA preemptively shutting the mine down, which appears at odds with other recent statements.
Here’s some tweets from the forum, thanks in large part to the reports at the Fairbanks Daily News-Miner, who know how to tweet right.
Libertarian candidate Jim McDermott is up at the House table. Fish didn’t get an invite for #akSen. #akelect pic.twitter.com/GYXW098ezG
— Matt Buxton (@FDNMPolitics) October 28, 2014
So far, some very Chamber of Commerce-style questions (oil taxes, fed overreach), which I guess shouldn’t be a surprise. #akelect — Tom Hewitt (@FDNMopinion) October 28, 2014
Sullivan batters Obama, ties Begich to him. Begich then goes onto offer laundry list of anti-EPA #Fairbanks accomplishments. #aksen #akelect
— Matt Buxton (@FDNMPolitics) October 28, 2014
National Petroleum Reserve will produce 16,000 barrels a day of oil next year. Sullivan walked away from those negotiations #AKSen — MarkBegich (@MarkBegich) October 28, 2014
Sullivan on Shell and NPR-A: “I don’t see these as successes.” The Admin and EPA are continuing delays. #akelect
— Matt Buxton (@FDNMPolitics) October 28, 2014
House is now talking about Alaska Native community. McDermott talks biz support. Young talks federal overreach. Dunbar compliments Young. — Matt Buxton (@FDNMPolitics) October 28, 2014
Immigration question. This has been a non-issue so far this campaign, interesting to see it brought up here. #aksen
— Tom Hewitt (@FDNMopinion) October 28, 2014
Now asking about executive amnesty. Sullivan: ITS NOT LEGAL. I’d oppose it. #akelect. — Matt Buxton (@FDNMPolitics) October 28, 2014
Begich rankled by Sullivan claim he supports amnesty, points to fact check on issue. #aksen
— Tom Hewitt (@FDNMopinion) October 28, 2014
Begich: your claim that I support executive amnesty is WRONG. #akelect #Aksen — Matt Buxton (@FDNMPolitics) October 28, 2014
Here’s the politifact on Sullivan’s claim that Begich supports amnesty. http://t.co/aw5ZW8srca #akelect #aksen
— Matt Buxton (@FDNMPolitics) October 28, 2014
Young says environmental species act has been expanded to include “every little thing that ever lived.” #akelect — Tom Hewitt (@FDNMopinion) October 28, 2014
Huh MT @FDNMPolitics: Q to Begich on EPA veto of Pebble Mine: I don’t support it. Just believe that mine doesn’t make sense. #akelect #aksen
— Nat Herz (@Nat_Herz) October 28, 2014
Begich says he doesn’t support Right to Work Legislation, answering question from Union. Sullivan says it should be up to states. #akelect — Matt Buxton (@FDNMPolitics) October 28, 2014
House question on partisan gridlock, how to fix it. Dunbar says campaign finance reform, ban on migration from Congress to lobbying #akelect — Tom Hewitt (@FDNMopinion) October 28, 2014
On whether or not he’ll support Harry Reid, Begich says “I haven’t made that decision yet” #akelect — Matt Buxton (@FDNMPolitics) October 28, 2014
Young, unsurprisingly, blames Nancy Pelosi for partisanship, says everything better with Rs in driver’s seat. #akelect — Tom Hewitt (@FDNMopinion) October 28, 2014
Sullivan has managed to mention either Obama or “this administration” in most every response. #akelect #aksen — Matt Buxton (@FDNMPolitics) October 28, 2014
Gonna be honest and say there have been zero surprises so far. Everything scripted, on message. I want #akgov debate back. #aksen #akelect — Tom Hewitt (@FDNMopinion) October 28, 2014
@MarkBegich stands by ad, work with @lisamurkowski. “All you talk about is Reid and Obama,” Begich says. “This is about Alaska.” #aksen — Austin Baird (@AustinBaird) October 28, 2014
Begich gets scattered applause when he talks about how annoying 97%/Harry Reid ad barrage is. First applause all debate. #aksen — Tom Hewitt (@FDNMopinion) October 28, 2014
3x huh MT @FDNMPolitics: Any ads you regret, Mark? #aksen. “I think the one we talked about his record could a been done differently” — Nat Herz (@Nat_Herz) October 28, 2014
Sullivan spends his 60 to continue to hammer on scare ads. Begich hammers Sullivan on social security changes. Pops in F35s #aksen #akelect — Matt Buxton (@FDNMPolitics) October 28, 2014
Oh man, these house questions are solid all of a sudden! Young asked about how effective he can be if he doesn’t have chairmanship. #akelect — Tom Hewitt (@FDNMopinion) October 28, 2014
Sullivan on HB77 “it has nothing to do with restricting hunting and fishing! I hunt and fish!” Good point. #akelect — Matt Buxton (@FDNMPolitics) October 28, 2014
@MarkBegich insists he never campaigned against Ted’s seniority. “Seniority does matter,” he says. #aksen — Austin Baird (@AustinBaird) October 28, 2014
Zinger by Sullivan at Begich re Senate not passing a budget for four years. #aksen — Rod Boyce (@FDNMeditor) October 28, 2014
Young bashes Obamacare gets big applause. Admits you can’t repeal it though. Better to fix it. #akelect — Matt Buxton (@FDNMPolitics) October 28, 2014
@repdonyoung points to @MarkBegich, says “he doesn’t understand it either,” talking #Obamacare. #aksen — Austin Baird (@AustinBaird) October 28, 2014
Sullivan tries to interrupt. Beigh: “LET ME FINISH, DAN!” #AKELECT. #AKSEN — Matt Buxton (@FDNMPolitics) October 28, 2014
Sullivan to Begich: you’re all taxy, spendy. #akelect #aksen — Matt Buxton (@FDNMPolitics) October 28, 2014
Both #aksen candidates on dark money reminiscent of Road Warrior: you could have put a stop to all this. pic.twitter.com/O8sU7IOJ1J — Tom Hewitt (@FDNMopinion) October 28, 2014
Young: I still have fire in my belly and maybe sometimes it burns a little to bright. #akelect #aksen — Matt Buxton (@FDNMPolitics) October 28, 2014
Word from someone in audience: Forrest Dunbar is impressive and Young is under control for now. #aksen #akelect — Amanda Coyne (@Amanda_Coyne) October 28, 2014
Begich “I don’t have a lot of love for the Koch brothers … I know what they’re up to and it’s not Alaska’s agenda.” #akelect #aksen
— Matt Buxton (@FDNMPolitics) October 28, 2014
Applause for Sullivan most boisterous of all. Loudest at tables with “I’m a proud Koch employee” T-shirts. #aksen — Tom Hewitt (@FDNMopinion) October 28, 2014



Hello,
To the many people at work and around town who have asked if the above comment is mine: NO. It’s someone else with the same name.
Sincerely,
Amy Carroll (from the Alaska Department of Fish and Game in Juneau Alaska)
Dunbar is one bright light. Just listen to him on radio. He knows everything about everything. He just seems like a genuinely nice guy too. http://www.alaskapublic.org/2014/10/24/u-s-house-candidate-forrest-dunbar/
I watched the debate yesterday. The biggest surprise to me was Dunbar.
First of all, between Begich and Sullivan, Begich comes off as a very slick article, I don’t believe anything he says. Unfortunately he is a very good communicator and I was impressed with how well he was able to get his bad ideas across. Sullivan, with whom I agree on the issues, is a poor debater. He appears awkward and waves his hands around in a very distracting manner. If he wins it is because voters know that Begich has been representing himself in DC, not us.
Don Young brought his best game to the debate. He was knowledgable, articulate and very relatable. I was surprised by how cogent he was given what I have been reading about him lately. Contrary to the tweets, he had the biggest applause line about Obamacare.
Dunbar was the surprise. He was also relatable, articulate, even likeable. He was properly respectful of Young’s experience, acknowledged he was a pretty conservative Democrat, and had good answers to tough questions. Too bad he isn’t a Republican. He has a definite political future in this state.
The Libertarian was just an idiot. His positions weren’t even libertarian in nature.
Begich comments “all you talk about is Reid and Obama” “this is about Alaska”….
Well, It’s no wonder whenever anyone talks to him they Mention Reid or Obama… Based on Begich’s voting record in the senate, 97 percent of the time You don’t get his attention unless you invoke Reid or Obama…
You’re welcome. It takes longer to pull these things together than it might look. Sometimes I wonder if it’s worth it.
Thanks for posting these Amanda! I’ve been waiting to hear what happened.
Put Alaska First now at $10 million spent for Begich and still going.
https://www.opensecrets.org/outsidespending/detail.php?cmte=C00544346&cycle=2014